Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Sabriel (Abhorsen,  #1)Sabriel by Garth Nix
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

It was a fantastic book. Garth Nix kept me breathless throughout Sabriel's adventure. There were just the right amount of background information to help the audience understand what went on in the novel, and there were just the right amount of questions left unanswered that will keep readers coming back for book 2. The book can also be read as a standalone, as the main storyline was well wrapped up.

However, since I rated The Way of Kings and both entries in Patrick Rothfuss' Kingkiller Chronicles as 5 stars, I felt that Sabriel in comparison falls short in several aspects, as it didn't give me the WOW feeling that i genuinely had with the other books previously mentioned.

In terms of world building, Garth Nix could have explained the magical system (the Charter) of the book, better. Right from page one, the author dumped "Charter" on the readers, without really delving in the mechanics of the magical system throughout the book. Readers were left to fend for themselves picking up clues along the way. In a way it works as it avoids a lot of info-dumping. In another way, it does make a lot of things very convenient for the characters as sometimes the characters got out of difficult situations a bit too easily (such as flying the Paperwing)

As for the characters, none of the characters stood out except for Mogget. Now that guy is fascinating. The schizophrenia and obvious wisdom makes for a very interesting combination. Sabriel is one strong woman, both mentally and magically. While I do admire her will and focus very much, she did come across as rather plain. No cracking wit, no exceptional insight (though this is probably a result of authorial intention to place the main character in a state of perpetual ignorance), no real flaw etc. She's just, for lack of a better term, meh.

I felt the relationship between Sabriel and Touchstone seemed rather rushed towards the end. After Sabriel finding Touchstone irritating for most of the book, the two inexplicably fell in love with each other. Perhaps it was because of the dire situation they found themselves in, you know, like crisis bringing together people. But still, I thought the interaction between them was written in a very cold manner.

I have to add that my perception of the book might have been coloured by firstly, speed reading most of the book, hence I may have missed out key details. It honestly is a very fast paced, a lot of things going on kind of story. And secondly, I accidentally discovered, to my great annoyance, that the next book will not feature Sabriel. Regardless of my thoughts towards the character design, I am still invested in her and would honestly want to read about things from her perspective again.

View all my reviews

Monday, April 23, 2012

Game of Thrones, Season 2 Episode 4

Its been quite long since I last checked in huh.

Today I wanna talk about the fantastic season 2 of the Game of Thrones. This is one of the best shows on TV these days. Besides the keen dialogue, perhaps the most attractive feature of the show is its cast of unique, flawed, vivid, unconventional characters. None of the characters has once behaved the way I expected him to, there's just about surprises around every turn.

This season, this show is complimented by its bevy of excellent actors (with the exception of the random supporting actor coming out for 5 minutes, such as the Lannister cousin today), imaginative costumes, detailed set designs, well-picked location settings.

Game of Thrones is by far, in my opinion, the best cable show I have seen. It mixes a whole range of themes: honor, politics, sex, violence. In short, it is a very, very intelligent show. Of course, a big portion of the credit has to go out to the original book author - George R.R. Martin. The first book, Game of Thrones didn't break the traditional fantasy mold much. But book 2 or season 2 is showing me just how smart this series is.

I LOVED IT~!

Unfortunately, as HBO Presents George RR Martin's freaky story in all its glory, sometimes the show just takes it even further than what my experienced mind can accept (True Blood and Spartacus veteran here). Season 2's episode 4 has just 2 such scenes - They are SO CREEPY/WEIRD/:SSSS

Its better if I just showed you.



Joffrey, Joffrey, Joffrey: this has got to be the creepiest teenager on TV EVER. At merely 15 years of age, he commands his knight to publicly humiliate and beat up his fiancee to be (another 15 year old girl), and here he forces two prostitutes (well-intended gifts from his uncle meant to help him becomes "less (mentally) clogged" ie stupid/weird/evil/twisted) to beat each other up.  

He is an idiot psychopath given all the power. He gets my vote for the most psychotic fictional sociopath ever created. Here's some worthy competition, Hannibal.

That said, I sincerely wonder where Jack Gleeson comes up with the "emotional memory" to portray such a twisted character in a believable fashion.




Scene 2

I can totally understand why the producers left this as the concluding scene for the episode. Despite all the weird out shit that this episode had, I doubt anybody has the appetite to watch anything else after this "unconventional" birthing scene.

When the woman removed her robe at first, you see a swollen belly, she lies down on the floor, spread eagled and starts yelling as if in labour. You think, she's pregnant and ready to give birth already? (she had sex with one of the king's  2 episodes back, promising to give him a son) Okay, maybe her magic sped up her pregnancy.

Then the camera shifts to her belly (first picture), and you see there's something seriously wrong about her stomach: its pulsating. Expanding, contracting, denting... Then the camera moves further down, and you see shit coming out from between her legs. Literally black smoke stuff, which then evolves into claws around her legs: some silently screaming, skull like, black monster.

Hmm, what's wrong with this picture?

I guess this is the point where people start dying. 

Yep, weird shit indeed.

I challenge anyone to find me anything weirder than this.

Wednesday, November 9, 2011

The Alloy of Law (Mistborn, #4)The Alloy of Law by Brandon Sanderson
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Brandon Sanderson does some stuff very, very well: action filled fantasies starring main characters who question their purpose and motivations set in a world where religion is considered in unconventional ways.

For the most part, Sanderson managed to deliver again an incredible fantasy adventure filled with laugh out loud moments and pulse racing scenes. Somehow, his seemingly simple prose was always extremely effective in describing complicated action scenes that were practically his hallmark.

I was initially apprehensive about The Alloy of Law because I was major fan of the original Mistborn Trilogy. While the ending was not entirely satisfactory in my opinion, it was nevertheless an ending that I have come to grudgingly accept as a bittersweet conclusion to an extraordinary fantasy series. But I thought, what the heck, this is Brandon Sanderson! One of my favourite fantasy author and I have yet failed to read any book written by him (except for WoT).

The story was an interesting addition to the original Mistborn lore. The applications of Allomancy to semi-modern gunfight sequences and Wax-Wayne’s hilarious interactions kept me turning the pages as time flew away.

However on the negative side, the world building wasn't as extensive as other Sanderson books. Religions have always been a strong focus in his worlds, but they were only alluded to in this case. This was something I felt remiss and could have expanded upon to clue in readers who aren't familiar with the original characters or to bridge better with the original series.

When I finished the book, I had many lingering questions. What the heck was bendalloy??? How did they discover bendalloy? Did Sanderson decide they need 8 pairs of metals and since theres the absence of attium and malatium, created an additional metal out of the blue? What's the God Metals?

Why were the aristocrats so useless in the ballroom scene? Have the mistings been relegated to mere courier services? What happened to keeping strong men in your household? That seems like a 180degrees change from 350 years ago. And having an entire ballroom of Aristocrats of noble descent and all of them could only cower in fear? Elend is a not hereditary Mistborn, so the kidnap theory was extremely flaky on my part as the reader.

I was very annoyed that Elend is known posthumously as Lord Mistborn, when Vin was obviously the stronger Mistborn warrior and the main character in the Mistborn series. What each religion has come to represent was also too vaguely explained.

So you will understand my disappointment that towards the end, instead of addressing these issues, Mr Sanderson chose to leave major cliffhangers in the final chapters to preempt possible future entries in the series. It went like this: after the main conflict was concluded, it was revealed that the main villain was manipulated (for unknown ulterior motives) by a higher-order villain. And surprise, surprise, Marsh and Sazed (ie GOD) are still there having a hand influencing the proceedings. Effects of Marsh's actions are another cliffhanger. Sazed didn't sound like Sazed at all. why did he help Wax? Why were Miles's actions considered so wrong as to justify God's intervention? I thought Wax was the more evil one meting out capital punishment for crimes of theft & kidnap. The crew had no initial plans to kill anybody.

Then the story ends. WTF? W-T-F!!!????

Considering there were no clear plans (if any at all?) that this series will continue in the future, I felt the ending was very bad. I was left feeling bereft of a satisfying closure to what I expected to be a standalone novel but all I could do was pull my hair in frustration.

As much as I may love the rest of the novel, the final chapter made me feel that the book was incomplete and spoiled the entire thing for me. I apologise for the schizophrenic tone in this review, for the book has clear merits and deficiencies, which accounts for the 3 stars.

P.s. Brandon Sanderson wrote in the preface he wanted to do an urban fantasy trilogy on the Mistborn world. By usual definitions urban fantasy is different from the steampunk setting of this book, which makes me doubt the continuance of this storyline, hence my utter frustration at the ending.

View all my reviews

Monday, October 17, 2011

Captain America: The First Avenger Review

Rating: 2.5/5 Stars




Lets get the good thing over first, its faster that way. Chris Evans (Captain America) is very, very good looking:


Yah, got that?



Now the bad. 

No, I am serious. The chance to stare at Chris Evans in his dashing army uniform (however brief those scenes were) was probably the only redeeming quality this film has got. 

Alright, maybe Stanley Tucci's performance was quite interesting. Still, too brief.

The film felt like it was a 2 part miniseries. The first half was how he got to become Captain America, with a climax scene in which he rescued his best buddy (huh? where did he come from?) from behind enemy lines. The 2nd half was...

Damn, that's how forgettable the whole excursion was.

Thing is, Captain America is one of the most...ordinary superhero that I have ever seen. He hasn't got Thor's god-like powers, Stark's smartass-ness, Black Widow's sexiness, Batman's mysteriousness, Spiderman's coolness. He's just... a guy with 4x metabolism as the normal human being. I guess the problem was it was never fully explained what were the extent of his powers before he started chasing the bad guys around.

To quote Brandon Sanderson's First Law of writing fantasy, a good fantasy has to clearly define the magical rules and boundaries within which the characters can act. Captain American was clearly shortchanged in this aspect.

After Captain America become Captain America, I am still just seeing the extra buff guy who's got ample beef. And the whole sequence on him parading as a carnival performer (to get people to buy bonds, raise morale, however funny that might be) did not help.

Strangely enough, this buff guy is able to outswim submarines, out run (1930s) cars, block bullets with a shield the size of half his chest (what about his legs?), withstand WMD charges with a flick of his arm, and FLY planes without any training whatsoever. Say what?

The villian in the film is Red Skull, played by the often reliable Hugo Weaving (LoTR, The Matrix), who's got his hands on super power mystical artefact with god-like energy powers which has enabled him to develop weapons which can vaporise a human being instantaneously and cause explosions. I assume that these are powerful enough characteristics of a weapon for America to become VERY concerned. Right.

Which leads me to the point that this is one of the lousiest villians i have ever seen. You got a mystical artefact and all you can do is vaporise human beings? The movie did not even demonstrate the extent of destructive capabilities these weapon! This guy has got no back up plans, lays out his grand plans on a map for all to see, and only knows how to yell at his minions when Captain America starts destroying his weapons factories.

After the 1 hour mark, the rest of the film truly felt like an eternity. Knowing full well that Captain America will emerge victorious (how else is he going to be in the upcoming Avengers' film?), I kept waiting for Red Skull to do something shocking that might actually make the audience care about how he was vanquished. Alas, it was too much to hope for.

In the end, it was just a meh superhero film filled with cliches. Cool graphics, hot guy + girl (whose attraction only did truly blossom after Chris Evans returned to his normal shape. Now what does that say, i wonder?), guns, explosions, uber high-tech vehicles, motivational kiss before the final showdown.

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz




I have seen many reviews talking about the disappointing qualities of the films leading up  to The Avengers (due 2012), and reviewers have expressed their hopes that they will finally do the characters justice by tying them all together in that film. As long as the Avengers isn't 5 hours long, I can't say I have got the same level of optimism.

Friday, September 23, 2011

步步惊心

Just spent the last week watching this drama and reading the original book. 
One of the saddest stories I ever read.
The beautiful cinematography of this scene in the last episode caught my eye.



I was struck by Number 14's devotion to the girl, despite the fact that the girl has never looked upon him with anything more than platonic love. 
Haiz, such a beautiful scene to send off the girl he loved.


This has got to be one of the best scenes in the whole show.
I think No 14's acting reached its apex in the show here.


I thought I had cried enough when I read the book. It took 1 hour of tears before I could finish the final few chapters. But the torrent continued as I watched the show.


What a 
beautiful,
depressing,
horrid, 
but lovely story.

Just like the main character, I am a masochist.

Wednesday, August 31, 2011

Miserere: An Autumn TaleMiserere: An Autumn Tale by Teresa Frohock

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


Original world building and action packed adventures. The world and magic system is very intricately linked with religion (no prize for guessing Ms Frohock's religion), specifically Christianity. This makes it very different from the usual high fantasy. As a non-religious person, it was surprising for me to find the system quite acceptable and that it somehow still works quite well in this series.

Interactions between the characters were well written. Miss Forhock has created distinctive and vivid characters - she does a fantastic job describing the inner worlds of characters' minds. However, some of the writing for action sequence do come across as jagged, impatient, lacking in rhythm.

My other complaint is the length of the novel. While it isn't exactly short, readers are left with a lot of unanswered questions (Can't the people have their own children? Where's the Gods of the other religions if there is only 1 heaven (Christian-centrism??)?) which could be attributed to either lack of comprehensive world-building, or this being the first book in a series.

Personally I feel the author could have provided more information about the world to draw the reader into the story. The cliff-hanger could also be more distinct to attract sustained readership.

Overall, it was still highly commendable for a debut effort.



View all my reviews

Saturday, August 13, 2011

French Films & Gaspard Ulliel


My love affair with French films started out with the lovely and passionate La Princesse de Montpensier (The Princess of Montpensier).

Through that amazing periodic piece film, I fell headlong in love with the extraordinarily beautiful and dashing Gaspard Ulliel:



My obsession led me to a viewing spree of Gaspard Ulliel's works, and in the process discovered the astoundingly adventurous and creative French film industry. My favourites aside from La Princesse de Montpensier have been the moving Les Choristes and utterly charming A Very Long Engagement (in which Ulliel's parts were amazing but far too brief)

This fantastic scene from A Very Long Engagement played a crucial part telling the love story of Mathilde and Manech, but this image showcases mindblowing cinematography which earned the film an Oscar nomination for Best Cinematography: