Sunday, September 21, 2014
Tower Lord: More Spinoff Than Sequel
Friday, April 11, 2014
Daughter of Smoke and Bone Series Review
Dreams of Gods and Monsters by Laini TaylorMy rating: 1 of 5 stars
After book 1 - 4 stars
After book 2 - 3.5 stars
Halfway through book 3 (and unlikely to finish) - 1 star
What started out as a promising start to a trilogy quickly fizzled out by the middle of Book 2. The logical inconsistencies and the plot conveniences relegate this series to just another YA crowd pleaser overflowing with flowery descriptions and lacking in substance.
Key questions about the magics introduced in Book 1 were left unanswered in Book 2 and 3. Glaring plot holes are prevalent throughout the book, indicative of how little effort Laini Taylor spent in world building.
All we know about magic in that world so far is that it takes pain to activate, and can only be done by someone with talent or pedigree.
If Akiva was able to do magic because he was descended from the Stelians, as the author had led us to believe in Book 1, how could Liraz, Hazael, Zuzanne and Karou able to learn and practice the magic if they do not share the same pedigree?
How were Zuzanne and Mik able to pick up magical glamour in just a few hours?
By Karou’s own admission, Madrigal spent years of observations and learning under Brimstone before she was able to start with the most basic of resurrection work – the teeth sorting. Even so, she was able to learn from Brimstone because she had a ‘natural affinity’ for magic. In comparison, Zuzanne was able to pick up teeth stringing by just observing Karou working over a few days. This is a glaring plot convenience.
What is the magical mechanism behind conjuring bodies? How does residual pain teeth relics actually translate to flesh and bones?
What if somebody died peacefully of old age, are the teeth still useable for resurrection purposes?
Why were teeth not harvested from Chimaera dead, angel dead and revenant dead? Why do teeth have to be gathered from the human world? There is a sizeable chimaera population in Eretz and plenty of dead bodies generated from the ongoing war, sufficient for a steady supply of teeth. Teeth harvested from Chimaera dead are likely already in the desired configuration, saving Brimstone tonnes of work. Angel teeth are also going to be extremely useful for giving flight abilities to the resurrected bodies. Idea huh?
The use of magical healing in book 2 is the mother of all dues ex machinas
If the final bodies of resurrected bodies closely follow the original creature from which teeth originated, what kind of teeth did Karou use to create winged chimaeras since birds do not have teeth? Do they only use bat teeth? Do the newly resurrected soldiers only have bat wings?
Why had Brimstone and Warlord mellowed after their initial penchant for brutality destroying the angels a millennia ago? With their portals into the human world, they could easily have brought in human weapons and eliminated angel threats when they were still weak and magic-less.
How did Brimstone create wishes from pain, and why were these magics never mentioned again in Book 2 and 3?
Longevity and age are glaringly inconsistent among different characters. Brimstone lived to a thousand years in his own natural body. This is apparent because there is no other resurrectionist in the Chimaera society and because his body was still showing the scars from the time when he was still a thrall to the angel mages. On the other hand, we have a Misbegotten soldier who was "already turning grey", a Seraphim emperor who was already looking aged, and very young individuals like Madrigal and Scarab who were only in their teens when they were first introduced. So how exactly does it work? Laini Taylor just keeps us guessing.
View all my reviews
Saturday, April 5, 2014
Captain America: The Winter Bore
| Cobie Smulders.... completely wasted in this film |
| This one too. Emily VanCamp |
| Scarlett Johansson's makeup in this film is horrible. |
Friday, March 21, 2014
Words of (un)Radiance
Words of Radiance by Brandon SandersonMy rating: 3 of 5 stars
I have waited for the Words of Radiance for 3 years, and an hour ago, I had finally finished this book. It has taken me an entire week to complete this book, and I feel… disappointed.
What’s good about this book? The climax where Kaladin finally found his place. It was one major emotional payoff after 1000+ pages. It’s equivalent to, if not better than, the plateau rescue Branderson wrote 2 years ago.
There's probably lots of fantastical aspects of this book that plenty of people have waxed lyrical about (see other 4-star or 5-star reviews).
However, let's also address what went wrong.
1. Kaladin’s unwavering loyalty towards Dalinar, contrasted with his abrasive attitude towards Adolin and Shallan
Although at times the friction between Kaladin and Adolin/Shallan had been able to drive the plot along, at others it completely drags the story down. Kaladin comes across as extremely prejudiced and narrow-minded, sometimes unnecessarily so. I thought he would have grown past this after the plateau rescue in book 1, but apparently not. In fact, it may just have gotten worse as he has even more opportunities to interact with light-eyes here in this book. Despite his prejudice, he remains exceedingly loyal towards Dalinar and even risked his own life saving Adolin from one very tight spot. What’s with this dichotomy of individual behavior? And don’t tell me youthful arrogance and idiocy, because that completely contradicts his role as a leader.
2. Why is Roshar so special? In Mistborn, we only had Hoid make a cameo as an informant, a role that could be appropriately described as a neutral observer. Yet, starting with Book 1 of The Stormlight Archives, we have seen Captain Demoux, Hoid, Vasher and even Nightblood having pivotal interactions with the Roshar characters and influencing the ongoing conflict. Perhaps this is Brandon Sanderon’s 3rd major Cosmere series, and cross-series appearances are just symptoms of an increasingly complex universe (think Marvel and DC). But the write-and-expand-model is uncomfortably reminiscent of The Vampire Diaries. So give me a rationale why they are so intent on stopping Odium (contrasted with Scadrial’s independent struggle against Ruin). Make me believe why .
3. Regardless of Sanderson’s actual intention to make Shallan the central character of Book 2, it is undeniable that Kaladin is yet the most pivotal character in the entire series so far. Cases in point: the plateau climax of Book 1, Kaladin’s ascension at the end of Book 2. As a result, I felt extremely disappointed at the one-dimensional character and simplistic story developments for Kaladin. I do appreciate the background stories on Shallan, but really, Sanderson’s style has always been to write a full series focusing on 1 key character and using peripheral characters to flesh out the world or provide alternate viewpoints. With Words of Radiance, Sanderson proved that he has yet to be able to develop a sufficiently complex and interesting second character capable of sustaining reader interest on its own merits.
4. Kaladin is abrasive and depressive. Shallan is a liar. Dalinar is a tyrant. Adolin is a peacock. Yes, viewed in one way, this is adding depth to characters. Viewed in another light, the developments are so atypical of readers’ perception of them from Book 1 that it becomes so much harder to relate to them. It made me question my existing assumptions about them, and in doing so, I don’t know who they are any more.
5. The ending: Everything written after the plateau Oathgate was activated is a BLOODY MESS. Dalinar's commands for the entire Alethkar encampment to uproot themselves and move into the shattered plans were apparently obeyed without question (WHAT? Didn't we have a chapter where Dalinar was ridiculed and discredited in front of EVERYONE earlier in the book?) The entire Alethkar army continued moving for weeks into the middle of the shattered plains, their capital be damned. The characters began to see visions in the tower. How Shallan got her shardblade before she accepted key truths about herself and became a radiant (contrasted with Kaladin)? How did Szeth and Eshonai get to Urithiru tower in earlier Interludes without owning a true shardblade to activate the Oathgate fabrial?
View all my reviews
Friday, February 28, 2014
My Infatuation With The Man From The Stars
The Stars, refers to You Who Came From The Stars, my latest drama infatuation that came to an end all too soon. It was a brief, passionate and heartbreaking affair.
Why did I love the drama so much? Was it because the puppy eyed Kim Soo Hyun? Was it because of the many times it made me laugh? Was it because of the spunky female lead? All of the above, but today I will tell you the truth. I was in love with the fantasy that you can somehow, somewhere find someone who would love and cherish you wholeheartedly. Someone who accepts and loves you, in spite of all your flaws.
I like Kim Soo Hyun for his acting, I admires Jun Ji Hyun for her talent and beauty. I love the characters. But would I want to marry Do Min Joon? Would I want to marry Kim Soo Hyun? No. I am not crazy. I love the drama for it brings together two lovers despite their differences and individual quirks.
Liking someone is admiring their strengths, but loving someone, is embracing their flaws.
An old adage, in various forms, incarnations and languages, yet nevertheless an accepted refrain in many cultures.
Facebook don't often make me depressed. Perhaps it's because everybody has a self protective mechanism, and mine unconsciously manifests as a natural avoidance of Facebook status updates. I am particularly perturbed at the Facebook-surfing habits some of my friends have - Facebook surfing actually seems like a genuine pastime for them to while away spare time.
On the other hand, there's me. I wall myself away in ignorance. I prefer to live in my own world, rather than be forced to face reality. Facebook updates are really a real-time, in-the-now reminder of a ticking clock and a world where people are moving on, and moving on, and moving on.
Years ago, those among my friends who have a significant other numbers in the minority. These days, I am the minority.
I am unwilling to face the fact of my minority status. Perhaps my sudden bout of melancholy will soon pass. Perhaps I should stop wallowing in self pity and go meet people, as my friend chides me. Perhaps I would find a new drama to distract myself.
No matter how I try to run, I can never outrun the facts. Blinding myself to facts, however, has got to be something I am getting better in.
Thursday, September 19, 2013
On Running Man
Today I deviate from my tradition of commenting exclusively on Western television shows and movies. Today, I talk about the reality show that has introduced me to Korea – its food, its pop culture, its entertainment industry, and the country in general.
In the long, long time since I last checked in, I have discovered another outlet for my love of film and television – Korea. It started with A Frozen Flower, and from then on, Running Man.
In my desperate attempts to sustain the beautiful yet painful experience of A Frozen Flower, I turned to the filmography of the lead actor and actress for inspiration. Sadly, the lead actor went into army after making A Frozen Flower, and his past works were mainly modern dramas. On the other hand, Song Ji-Hyo's filmography proved to be a treasure trove of wonders. Running Man, was one of them.
At that point of time, my only experience with reality shows have been from Hollywood, where generic franchises like Survivor, American Idol, Project Runway, Newlyweds are reigned by C or lower - listed entertainers and actors. It is a realm where respectable actors and entertainers do not tread. So it came as a great surprise to me, how can an actress as popular and successful as Song Ji-hyo, stay on at Running Man for 80 or 90 episodes (spanning over more than 1 year), without any other notable works during this period? What was this reality show that could capture not only the audience's attention, but the actress' heart?
So, on I went to take a sampler on Youtube. As expected, the quality and selection of videos on YouTube was extremely limited due to copyrighted content (Korea was extremely good at coordinating censorship of its copyright contents with YouTube). But I managed to find a respectably cut video, the first episode I ever watched, of an episode featuring a member of SNSD. I am oblivious to the appeal of SNSD, but just from glimpsing the interactions among the regular members, I was hooked.
Running Man's format is that of an urban Amazing Race. Every week, members along with the weekly guests are divided into separate teams and made to compete with each other. The filming location for each episode varies. Different challenges are thought up of each week, frequently in conjunction to showcase the locale's unique attractions, food, or people. At the end of each episode, a final winner is declared and a whole new competition begins anew the following episode. In the whole time I was in University, I have never discovered another show that made me laugh as hard, as often, and as true. It was the members' wit, passion, silliness, camaraderie and competitiveness that really shone through in every episode of my beloved show. For 3 weeks, I did little else besides catching up on the backlog of running man. It was running man for breakfast, lunch, tea, dinner and supper. And my favourite member, doubtless to say, was Song Ji-Hyo.
Ji-hyo is not book smart, or even remotely good at intellectual games. As the sole female member on the team, she is outgunned and outmuscled, literally, but never outwitted. Many a times, she stood aside and pretended to be the weak, harmless, fragile observer, while the rest of the members duked it out. In the final crucial moment, she rears up and executes stunning game changing surprises, winning the game on her intelligence, if not physical strength.
Korean reality shows are also interesting in the way they like to pair up couples in their roster of hosts and entertainers - "The Loveline". Entertainers participating in the "Loveline" are expected to flirt and be affectionate towards each other on a regular basis. The "Loveline" is set up so that audiences can voyeuristically enjoy the development of make-believe on-screen romance, a la mini-The Bachelor, and therefore become even more emotionally invested in the entertainers presenting the show. Despite having developed a relatively innovative game structure, Running Man yet operated in a generic Korean reality show environment and it was no surprise that several episodes into the show, the production team decided there is a need to "create" a "loveline" for the sole female member.
And the production team's choice was... the unlikely Kang Gary. Rapper Gary was at first sight, quiet, awkward, plain looking. A veritable guy-next-door on his first reality show, not the first person I would pick for Song Ji-hyo when they also have the pretty Song Joong Ki and the muscleman Kim Jong Kook. It was the first loveline for both Song Ji-hyo and Kang Gary; both were reluctant to be thrust into the situation and were extremely awkward and embarrassed at the start. However, the years went by, Gary became ever more confident in his entertainment skills, occasionally blurting comical witty one-liners. When Ji-hyo was revealed to be dating her management firm's CEO in real life, their love-line evolved from pretend affections to hilarious unrequited feelings from Gary. Most importantly, he became the direct complement to Ji-hyo: he was strong where Ji-hyo was weak, straightforward where Ji-hyo was devious, and underneath it all, they shared a solid friendship from working together for 3 years.
On the most recent episode aired on 15 September, Gary kissed Song Ji-hyo!!!(On the cheek, as part of a challenge) My first reaction was, "That's frigging awesome!!! So sweet!!!!" My second thought was, "Why the hell do I care when I know it's not real?" My third thought was of an episode long ago, when they had a teenage idol guest who said, "I am such a big fan of the Monday Couple (referring to Gary and Ji-hyo who only dates on Monday when Running Man films), I really want to wish them well!" Which brings me to a full circle – how did I write everything in the last 3 paragraphs, and still be so invested in a relationship that I know is as manufactured as plastic? How did people in the entertainment industry who help to create the illusion of such false truths, become so invested? What is this mystical allure of the loveline, even when people know it's not real?
Alas, I have no answers. I am as much the next regular person who had fallen under Running Man's spell. Running Man makes me happy. I watch it the first opportunity I get, whether is it Monday or Tuesday or Wednesday. It's had its boring moments, especially when they recycles silly challenges like the ddakji, but otherwise, it is the highlight of my week. I admire the production team's creativity, sadistic humor and meticulous planning. I love the members' cohesiveness, dedication and occasional absurdity. Truth, I love Running Man.
Monday, October 8, 2012
Homeland Season 2 Episode 2
The second episode of the 'critically lauded' series is a classic example of how absurd Homeland has gotten. Major plot hole after plot hole appeared throughout the episode. Here are some really glaring ones:
Major Plot-hole #1:
Brody getting invited into a top secret live broadcast of DoD operation without proper vetting, removal of electronic devices and what-not. Are we talking about the Pentagon here? Or is this some random police station? Are we talking about a 6-month old Congressman here or a 20 year US Army General?
If Abu Nasir is that big a terrorist they talked about in Season 1, this has got to be a pretty serious operation attended by the President, Army General, Special Ops Director, all the major bureaucratic leaders of the Pentagon. How am i supposed to believe that a 6-MONTH OLD CONGRESSMAN has got a seat reserved for him near the head of the table? Right opposite of Vice President Walden? ARE YOU KIDDING ME?
![]() |
| How could Brody be important enough to deserve a seat with the other Army generals and the Vice President himself? |
Major Plot-hole #2:
![]() |
| Hey, obvious much? |
The alternative being a message being bounced around through several people so that it is less likely to be traced back to him, but this would be nigh impossible to warn Abu Nasir on time.
Looking at the speed of message transmission, Brody has to have had Abu Nasir on speed dial. If its that easy and undetectable, why bother with making Roya the middleman? Just continue sending messages in code, why don't you?
Major Plot-hole #3:
Dear Brody, if you voluntarily let Abu Nasir 'live another day', you should be prepared to face the consequences. Why would you get upset about having to continue to act as one of his puppets? Did you ever consider, if he had died, you would have been freed immediately to execute your own version of morally justified retaliation on the US government, free from constraints and dictations from the fucktard?
No? Well then, your amazing lack of intellectual powess certainly disqualifies you from a congressman position. Ah wait, I remembered Sarah Palin had been running for Vice President a while back. Look at what kind of influence you have, Palin, politicians in every show don't have to be smart no more.
Major Plot-hole #4.1:
Carrie, WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU THINKING? I mean, there's no way you would think she's CIA trained looking at how rashly she jumped out of the vehicle. Option 1: Leaving your companions amidst hostile forces to go into an unknown area blind looking for God knows what, with minimal chance of finding anything. Option 2: Stay with your companions and get out of the area ASAP. No prize for guessing which option smart Carrie picked. Such brainless actions fully justify why she deserves to be kicked out of the CIA. She is a danger to other agents and herself.
![]() |
| Definitely someone with a problem |
Major Plot-hole #4.2
Related to Plot-hole 4.1, is the amazing turn of events following Carrie's rash action: Leaving your companions to hostile forces, entering an unknown area without facing any resistance (the building and specific apartment just so happens to be abandoned by inhabitants. No matter that Muslims are polygamous and it is impossible for that Muslim lady to be the only wife of a Hezbollah COMMANDER.) Such a conspicuously blonde lady was able to move unmolested around a Hezbollah stronghold when America is having major tensions with the Muslim Middle East. (though the hostile people did come after her after some time later) A group of foreign looking individuals driving a GENERAL MOTORS COMPANY hatchback into and stopping in a Hezbollah controlled area.
Then the most amazing thing is Carrie is taking all these risks to grab some random documents from a table top in a freely-accessible study room. I mean, if this isn't a show, there's no way a CIA agent would be this STUPID, right? You just have to consider the odds to know random documents lying around is not gonna be worth the risk. Can you imagine dying for some electricity bills? I got plenty of those lying around on my study table.
There's are other more minor plot holes, such as Saul's never-ending blind faith in Carrie and the Brody family's meteoric rise in economic and social standings. But those simply pales in comparison to the above developments. With some of the most absurd plot lines involving Brody, it will take an actor with significant charisma and conviction to pull them off convincingly. I for one, was not sold by Daniel Lewis' 'critically acclaimed' subtle (read: bland) acting.
Wednesday, May 9, 2012
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
It was a fantastic book. Garth Nix kept me breathless throughout Sabriel's adventure. There were just the right amount of background information to help the audience understand what went on in the novel, and there were just the right amount of questions left unanswered that will keep readers coming back for book 2. The book can also be read as a standalone, as the main storyline was well wrapped up.
However, since I rated The Way of Kings and both entries in Patrick Rothfuss' Kingkiller Chronicles as 5 stars, I felt that Sabriel in comparison falls short in several aspects, as it didn't give me the WOW feeling that i genuinely had with the other books previously mentioned.
In terms of world building, Garth Nix could have explained the magical system (the Charter) of the book, better. Right from page one, the author dumped "Charter" on the readers, without really delving in the mechanics of the magical system throughout the book. Readers were left to fend for themselves picking up clues along the way. In a way it works as it avoids a lot of info-dumping. In another way, it does make a lot of things very convenient for the characters as sometimes the characters got out of difficult situations a bit too easily (such as flying the Paperwing)
As for the characters, none of the characters stood out except for Mogget. Now that guy is fascinating. The schizophrenia and obvious wisdom makes for a very interesting combination. Sabriel is one strong woman, both mentally and magically. While I do admire her will and focus very much, she did come across as rather plain. No cracking wit, no exceptional insight (though this is probably a result of authorial intention to place the main character in a state of perpetual ignorance), no real flaw etc. She's just, for lack of a better term, meh.
I felt the relationship between Sabriel and Touchstone seemed rather rushed towards the end. After Sabriel finding Touchstone irritating for most of the book, the two inexplicably fell in love with each other. Perhaps it was because of the dire situation they found themselves in, you know, like crisis bringing together people. But still, I thought the interaction between them was written in a very cold manner.
I have to add that my perception of the book might have been coloured by firstly, speed reading most of the book, hence I may have missed out key details. It honestly is a very fast paced, a lot of things going on kind of story. And secondly, I accidentally discovered, to my great annoyance, that the next book will not feature Sabriel. Regardless of my thoughts towards the character design, I am still invested in her and would honestly want to read about things from her perspective again.
View all my reviews
Monday, April 23, 2012
Game of Thrones, Season 2 Episode 4
Today I wanna talk about the fantastic season 2 of the Game of Thrones. This is one of the best shows on TV these days. Besides the keen dialogue, perhaps the most attractive feature of the show is its cast of unique, flawed, vivid, unconventional characters. None of the characters has once behaved the way I expected him to, there's just about surprises around every turn.
This season, this show is complimented by its bevy of excellent actors (with the exception of the random supporting actor coming out for 5 minutes, such as the Lannister cousin today), imaginative costumes, detailed set designs, well-picked location settings.
Game of Thrones is by far, in my opinion, the best cable show I have seen. It mixes a whole range of themes: honor, politics, sex, violence. In short, it is a very, very intelligent show. Of course, a big portion of the credit has to go out to the original book author - George R.R. Martin. The first book, Game of Thrones didn't break the traditional fantasy mold much. But book 2 or season 2 is showing me just how smart this series is.
I LOVED IT~!
Unfortunately, as HBO Presents George RR Martin's freaky story in all its glory, sometimes the show just takes it even further than what my experienced mind can accept (True Blood and Spartacus veteran here). Season 2's episode 4 has just 2 such scenes - They are SO CREEPY/WEIRD/:SSSS
Its better if I just showed you.
Scene 2
When the woman removed her robe at first, you see a swollen belly, she lies down on the floor, spread eagled and starts yelling as if in labour. You think, she's pregnant and ready to give birth already? (she had sex with one of the king's 2 episodes back, promising to give him a son) Okay, maybe her magic sped up her pregnancy.
Then the camera shifts to her belly (first picture), and you see there's something seriously wrong about her stomach: its pulsating. Expanding, contracting, denting... Then the camera moves further down, and you see shit coming out from between her legs. Literally black smoke stuff, which then evolves into claws around her legs: some silently screaming, skull like, black monster.
Wednesday, November 9, 2011
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Brandon Sanderson does some stuff very, very well: action filled fantasies starring main characters who question their purpose and motivations set in a world where religion is considered in unconventional ways.
For the most part, Sanderson managed to deliver again an incredible fantasy adventure filled with laugh out loud moments and pulse racing scenes. Somehow, his seemingly simple prose was always extremely effective in describing complicated action scenes that were practically his hallmark.
I was initially apprehensive about The Alloy of Law because I was major fan of the original Mistborn Trilogy. While the ending was not entirely satisfactory in my opinion, it was nevertheless an ending that I have come to grudgingly accept as a bittersweet conclusion to an extraordinary fantasy series. But I thought, what the heck, this is Brandon Sanderson! One of my favourite fantasy author and I have yet failed to read any book written by him (except for WoT).
The story was an interesting addition to the original Mistborn lore. The applications of Allomancy to semi-modern gunfight sequences and Wax-Wayne’s hilarious interactions kept me turning the pages as time flew away.
However on the negative side, the world building wasn't as extensive as other Sanderson books. Religions have always been a strong focus in his worlds, but they were only alluded to in this case. This was something I felt remiss and could have expanded upon to clue in readers who aren't familiar with the original characters or to bridge better with the original series.
When I finished the book, I had many lingering questions. What the heck was bendalloy??? How did they discover bendalloy? Did Sanderson decide they need 8 pairs of metals and since theres the absence of attium and malatium, created an additional metal out of the blue? What's the God Metals?
Why were the aristocrats so useless in the ballroom scene? Have the mistings been relegated to mere courier services? What happened to keeping strong men in your household? That seems like a 180degrees change from 350 years ago. And having an entire ballroom of Aristocrats of noble descent and all of them could only cower in fear? Elend is a not hereditary Mistborn, so the kidnap theory was extremely flaky on my part as the reader.
I was very annoyed that Elend is known posthumously as Lord Mistborn, when Vin was obviously the stronger Mistborn warrior and the main character in the Mistborn series. What each religion has come to represent was also too vaguely explained.
So you will understand my disappointment that towards the end, instead of addressing these issues, Mr Sanderson chose to leave major cliffhangers in the final chapters to preempt possible future entries in the series. It went like this: after the main conflict was concluded, it was revealed that the main villain was manipulated (for unknown ulterior motives) by a higher-order villain.
Then the story ends. WTF? W-T-F!!!????
Considering there were no clear plans (if any at all?) that this series will continue in the future, I felt the ending was very bad. I was left feeling bereft of a satisfying closure to what I expected to be a standalone novel but all I could do was pull my hair in frustration.
As much as I may love the rest of the novel, the final chapter made me feel that the book was incomplete and spoiled the entire thing for me. I apologise for the schizophrenic tone in this review, for the book has clear merits and deficiencies, which accounts for the 3 stars.
P.s. Brandon Sanderson wrote in the preface he wanted to do an urban fantasy trilogy on the Mistborn world. By usual definitions urban fantasy is different from the steampunk setting of this book, which makes me doubt the continuance of this storyline, hence my utter frustration at the ending.
View all my reviews
Monday, October 17, 2011
Captain America: The First Avenger Review
Lets get the good thing over first, its faster that way. Chris Evans (Captain America) is very, very good looking:
Yah, got that?
Alright, maybe Stanley Tucci's performance was quite interesting. Still, too brief.
The film felt like it was a 2 part miniseries. The first half was how he got to become Captain America, with a climax scene in which he rescued his best buddy (huh? where did he come from?) from behind enemy lines. The 2nd half was...
Damn, that's how forgettable the whole excursion was.
Thing is, Captain America is one of the most...ordinary superhero that I have ever seen. He hasn't got Thor's god-like powers, Stark's smartass-ness, Black Widow's sexiness, Batman's mysteriousness, Spiderman's coolness. He's just... a guy with 4x metabolism as the normal human being. I guess the problem was it was never fully explained what were the extent of his powers before he started chasing the bad guys around.
To quote Brandon Sanderson's First Law of writing fantasy, a good fantasy has to clearly define the magical rules and boundaries within which the characters can act. Captain American was clearly shortchanged in this aspect.
After Captain America become Captain America, I am still just seeing the extra buff guy who's got ample beef. And the whole sequence on him parading as a carnival performer (to get people to buy bonds, raise morale, however funny that might be) did not help.
Strangely enough, this buff guy is able to outswim submarines, out run (1930s) cars, block bullets with a shield the size of half his chest (what about his legs?), withstand WMD charges with a flick of his arm, and FLY planes without any training whatsoever. Say what?
The villian in the film is Red Skull, played by the often reliable Hugo Weaving (LoTR, The Matrix), who's got his hands on super power mystical artefact with god-like energy powers which has enabled him to develop weapons which can vaporise a human being instantaneously and cause explosions. I assume that these are powerful enough characteristics of a weapon for America to become VERY concerned. Right.
Which leads me to the point that this is one of the lousiest villians i have ever seen. You got a mystical artefact and all you can do is vaporise human beings? The movie did not even demonstrate the extent of destructive capabilities these weapon! This guy has got no back up plans, lays out his grand plans on a map for all to see, and only knows how to yell at his minions when Captain America starts destroying his weapons factories.
After the 1 hour mark, the rest of the film truly felt like an eternity. Knowing full well that Captain America will emerge victorious (how else is he going to be in the upcoming Avengers' film?), I kept waiting for Red Skull to do something shocking that might actually make the audience care about how he was vanquished. Alas, it was too much to hope for.
In the end, it was just a meh superhero film filled with cliches. Cool graphics, hot guy + girl (whose attraction only did truly blossom after Chris Evans returned to his normal shape. Now what does that say, i wonder?), guns, explosions, uber high-tech vehicles, motivational kiss before the final showdown.
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
I have seen many reviews talking about the disappointing qualities of the films leading up to The Avengers (due 2012), and reviewers have expressed their hopes that they will finally do the characters justice by tying them all together in that film. As long as the Avengers isn't 5 hours long, I can't say I have got the same level of optimism.
Friday, September 23, 2011
æ¥æ¥æƒŠå¿ƒ
I think No 14's acting reached its apex in the show here.
Wednesday, August 31, 2011
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Original world building and action packed adventures. The world and magic system is very intricately linked with religion (no prize for guessing Ms Frohock's religion), specifically Christianity. This makes it very different from the usual high fantasy. As a non-religious person, it was surprising for me to find the system quite acceptable and that it somehow still works quite well in this series.
Interactions between the characters were well written. Miss Forhock has created distinctive and vivid characters - she does a fantastic job describing the inner worlds of characters' minds. However, some of the writing for action sequence do come across as jagged, impatient, lacking in rhythm.
My other complaint is the length of the novel. While it isn't exactly short, readers are left with a lot of unanswered questions (Can't the people have their own children? Where's the Gods of the other religions if there is only 1 heaven (Christian-centrism??)?) which could be attributed to either lack of comprehensive world-building, or this being the first book in a series.
Personally I feel the author could have provided more information about the world to draw the reader into the story. The cliff-hanger could also be more distinct to attract sustained readership.
Overall, it was still highly commendable for a debut effort.
View all my reviews
Saturday, August 13, 2011
French Films & Gaspard Ulliel

Thursday, August 4, 2011
Justified (Timothy Olyphant)
Monday, July 25, 2011
True Blood Season 4, Episode 5

Wednesday, March 2, 2011
Brandon Sanderson's Review of The Wise Man's Fear
Side note: I am waiting to have the time to read The Wise Man's Fear. Wow the name of the wind was 250,000 words, and that took me well over a day. It was pretty exhausting to read. The Wise Man's Fear is in fact nearly 400,000 words long
(:
Review of THE WISE MAN'S FEAR by Patrick Rothfuss
In case you haven't heard, today is the release day of the long-awaited sequel to The Name of the Wind, a delightful debut fantasy novel by Patrick Rothfuss. I've had the privilege of reading the book, so I thought I'd post a heads-up here for those of you who read my blog, along with a review. (Of sorts.) Also, a reminder, I did an interview with Pat (and he kind of interviewed me back) for Amazon. You can read it at this link.
PART ONE: A REVIEW OF THE WISE MAN'S FEAR
All right, so the review of Wise Man's Fear will focus on one question: Is it as good as the first?
The answer is . . . yes, and I feel that it's quite a bit better. (That is saying a lot.)
There's the review. I figure that those of you reading this blog will either:
Have read Name of the Wind and liked it, so that review should be more than enough for you.
Have read Name of the Wind and didn't like it. If so, I respect your opinion, even though you're obviously a crazy person.
Haven't yet read Name of the Wind, so giving you an extensive review of the second book would really just be a big confusing spoiler.
PART TWO: GO BUY IT
This is a very, very good book. If you liked the first, might I suggest that you go out and purchase yourself a copy this week? Pat may not mention it himself, but first-week sales are very helpful in giving a book good momentum. It will determine how long the book stays on shelves, how good its placement is in weeks to come, and how aggressively the sequel will be ordered by bookstores.
As I always state for my own books, if you're not a hardcover buyer, don't feel guilty not going out to get it—as authors, we like you to consume books as you prefer to consume them. Library, hardcover, ebook, paperback . . . your call. However, if you ARE intending to read Wise Man's Fear in hardcover, buying it early rather than late is always a nice sign for the author. Also, I've got a selfish reason for wanting Pat to sell well. I'd very much like to have a nice, friendly rivalry going with the chap. The Way of Kings hit #7 on the New York Times list. If Pat can hit in the top five with this book, it will give me something to shoot for.
(Honestly, I'm hoping he hits #1. It's well within the realm of possibility for this book, and he deserves it. It will help the entire genre if this book sells well, as it will prove that big epic fantasy books by newer authors are still viable, and will also prove that excellence will be rewarded by the readership.)
PART THREE: A LONGER REVIEW (KIND OF)
Okay, so, I'm off on a tangent again. Let's bring this back into focus. I'm going to assume that some of you haven't read Name of the Wind yet. I often suggest it to people; it's become—alongside Tigana, Eye of the World, and Dragonsbane—one of my top recommendations for fantasy readers. Often, however, people ask why they should read the book. Why do I recommend it?
Because it's awesome.
Why is it awesome?
This often stops me. Why IS Pat's writing awesome?
Well, the books have an absolutely wonderful magic system. One part science, one part historical pseudoscience, one part magical wonder. It's the type of magic system that I'm always delighted to read, and ranks among my favorites in fantasy literature. But that alone doesn't describe why the books are awesome.
In many ways, Name of the Wind is like an old, familiar coat. A young man orphaned at a young age. Time spent on the streets living as a thief and a street rat. A wizards' school. Those who have not liked the book have often complained about the familiar tropes. What I love about how Pat uses these tropes, however, is the realism he strives to impart.
I view this story like a Batman Begins-type realism reboot of many classic fantasy tropes. We get to hear the legends of Kvothe, then read the truth, and make the connections of how things spiraled from realistic to fantastic. The way Pat does this is genius. In some places, you can barely pick out the tropes he is using—after one sequence in Wise Man's Fear, I found myself laughing uproariously as I realized the mythological foundation for the sequence. There are familiar tropes, but they're taken and made so new and fresh that you have to peer through several layers of silk to see them for what they are. In other cases, there is delightful originality.
Those things, however, also fail to describe why the books are awesome.
Kvothe is a very compelling hero, very classical in that he's widely accomplished yet marred by a single dominating flaw. (In this case, his temper.) He is witty, charming, and so wonderfully capable that he's a delight to read about. (Particularly following much of the current fiction I've read, which seems to take the utmost pains to make certain I don't like anyone I'm reading about.) He's noble, yet brash, and is clever, but inexperienced. (Which makes him dense on occasion.) He lives.
But even that is not what truly makes these books awesome.
In the end, I think that if I distill why I've loved these books so much more than others, it's because of this: They're beautiful. Wise Man's Fear is a BEAUTIFUL book to read. Masterful prose, a sense of cohesion to the storytelling, a wonderful sense of pacing . . . None of that is the reason for the awesomeness any more than a single dab of paint is the reason why a Monet is a thing of wonder. But if you step back to look and digest the piece as a whole—not thinking too much about the parts—you are left with a sense of awe.
There is a beauty to Pat's writing that defies description. Perhaps if Kvothe were here, he could write an appropriate song that would capture it.
Brandon
p.s. As this is of note to many of those in my audience, I feel that I should mention that this book contains a fair bit more sex than the previous volume did. Pat avoids graphic details, but there are events in the latter half of the book that some readers may find discomforting.
Thursday, February 24, 2011
Review of Iron Crowned - Richelle Mead
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
I was a big, big fan of the Dark Swan series. I loved the idea of Eugenie getting lured away by Dorian, and Richelle Mead daring to take on the sensitive issue of rape in the previous book, Thorn Queen.
After reading this book, eugenie markham just shot straight to the top of my most disliked heroine characters list(from urban fantasies/romances).
eugenie Markham is one flawed lady.
Honestly, she's unbelievably selfish, shortsighted and delusional, not to mention a closet nymphomaniac.
I think Richelle Mead made a really bad decision keeping the love triangle alive and kicking, particularly since it makes little sense to break them up, bring them back, and repeat.
The novel's overall pace is very quick, it doesn't bog you down with things you do not want to read about. The writing style, as with all Richelle Mead's narratives, are simple and straight to the point. Sometimes it works when you have got strong, well written characters like Georgina Kincaid to move the storyline along, but I think this book failed in this aspect.
Yes, Eugenie is super tough, but she's so emotionally unstable its probably best if she's committed to an institution (okay this is probably taking it too far. but you catch my drift).
This installment took the storyline in a darn awkward direction.
The way Richelle Mead ended the book is not a cliffhanger. It is the general direction for the next 10 (?) books, or so. The only way I see this cliffhanger resolved is a storyline extending decades into the future.
Overall, a disappointing addition to Ms Richelle Mead's resume. But then since I didn't like the vampire academy series (except for the first book) either, I would say Ms Mead's works are probably not my cup of tea any more.
View all my reviews
Saturday, February 19, 2011
Review of Dreams of a Dark Warrior - Kresley Cole
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
Honestly, the best book I have read so far this year.
Such well crafted and vivid characters. Kresley cole had whetted our appetite with hints of this story every since the first book of the IAD series, a Hunger Like No Other. It has taken 11 books for her to finally get the story out. And boy, she doesn't disappoint.
This story features a hero darker than that from any of her previous books. This follows the recent trend of paranormal romance books featuring dark, haunted and scarred heroes. Notably from the Black Dagger Brotherhood, Larissa Ione's Demonica, etc etc.
But I daresay that Kresley Cole did better in this book than any of the other authors have managed in crafting a believable romance between a heroine and the dark, dark hero.
Dreams of a Dark Warrior narrates the 'thousand year' romance between the antagonistically immature Regin, and Berserker reincarnate Declan Chase/Aidan the Fierce. Regin is one spunky character capable of uttering the most inappropriate comments that greatly lightens the mood of the book. She's the strong, arrogant and utterly fearless female warrior that can only be one of Kresley Cole's creations.
Kresley Cole was very brave to add such a dark intensity to Regin and Chase's interactions (people who has read the book will understand what I am talking about). Many people would probably Chase's treatment of Regin a turnoff, but in this case, I think it worked very well because it helps to emphasize Chase's internal struggles later on. It was these scenes that left me cringing with horror and heartache and sympathy all at the same time.
This is one powerful romance. In the course of one book, one manages to feel sorrow, joy, pain, humor, sympathy. Most importantly, the romance was believable, as both Regin and Chase fit together so well. I perceive no age problems, and their love is made genuine by the thousand year experience. In my opinion, Kresley Cole's best work so far yet.
A must read for all paranormal romance fans.
View all my reviews













